1922 AD - 1 / January
"Pro Anglo Irish Treaty - Anti Treaty"
1922 January: Sir James Craig
the leader of the "Official" Unionists met
with
Michael Collins in London, where he stated that he
would "protect" the Irish Catholics in the
6 Counties that would be "artificially partitioned" by the
British
Imperial Coalition Government
from the 9 Counties in the
Ulster Province, if Michael Collins
would "withdraw" the boycott, and also get those who were
previously "kidnapped" released and he also agreed to
"revise" the "Boundary Commission," so that each of
them could
appoint a "representative" for preliminary talks, but
they would be the ones to make the final arrangements.
January:
The
American Association for the Recognition of the Irish Republic,
which had been set up there previously by
Eamonn de Valera
had by now grown "immensely" and had a staggering total of
700,000
members.
January 3rd:
The
Dail
Eireann / Irish Assembly reconvened to continue the "Anglo
- Irish Treaty
Debate" were
Eammon de Valera's
shares
had "dropped" immensely in the eyes of many of his previous followers,
as he was against the
"Pro
- Treaty" group, with his
"personal"
opposition due mainly to the need to have to take the
"Oath of Allegiance"
to the
German Saxe - Coburg British King and he
was also
losing favour with those of the determined
Irish Republicans,
who now also considered that his
"Document No 2" was also only a
"sell out" to the
British
Imperial Government, and added to this also was that the fact about his
"dispute" with
the long time Irish Independence supporter
John Devoy from the
Clann na Gael / The
Ooganization
in
America
over his
Cuba statement, was slowly becoming
"common knowledge" in
Ireland.
January 4th:
Sean O Kelly, Liam Mellowes, P.
Rutledge, Art O Connor
and
Sean Moylan
who now represented
the definitive "Anti
- Treaty" group, met with the "Pro
- Treaty" group composed of
P.J. O Hogan,
Joseph Mac Guinness, Michael
Hayes and
Eoin O Duffy,
and except for
Liam Mellowes they all agreed that
Eamonn de Valera should be "retained" as the
Priomh Aire
of the
2nd
Dail Eireann and that the
Irish Provisional Government should be
allowed to function "normally" under the auspices of the 2nd
Dail Eireann / Irish Assembly.
They also agreed that
the Irish
Republican Army / I.R.A. should
be also under the control of the
Irish Provisional Government,
who should also be the ones to sign the
"Anglo - Irish
Treaty" and although
Arthur Griffith
and
Michael Collins "agreed" to their conditions,
Eamonn de Valera
was still "against" any compromise, and
he
"refused" to accept them, as he wanted his own
"No 2 Document" approved
instead. To this end, they held a further meeting that night, but the "Anti
- Treaty" group by then, had "changed" their position,
and decided that they would "not stand" by their original
agreement either.
January 6th:
The 2nd Dail
Eireann / Irish Assembly met in
"Private Session" again,
where the
"Committee's"
report
was "denied" discussion, and the staid
Cathal Brugha and
Michael Collins clashed
"personally" during the
debate, and
Eamonn de
Valera
then tended his "resignation" again, which
was considered by all present to be a personal "stunt" by him to
force the issue as a "Red Herring,"
hoping it would bring about a "new"
Dail Eireann
Cabinet and he could then introduce his
"Document No 2 once
again,"
but eventually
the mild - mannered Arthur Griffith
was able to
talk him out of it, "For the good of
Ireland, as they already had enough to
deal with sorting out the problems over the "Anglo - Irish
Treaty."
January 7th:
The final day of the "Anglo - Irish
Treaty
Debate"
was held by the
120 members
of the
2nd
Dail Eireann / Irish Assembly in the
Council Chamber of University
College in
Dublin, were
Michael Collins put forward his own
personal view that those in authority in England
over the "Centuries" had
destroyed the
Gaelic way of life in
Ireland,
but the
"Anglo - Irish Treaty"
would bring
security and
freedom to finally remove their "stranglehold" and
Cathal Brugha
once again attacked
Michael Collins
"personally," while
Eamonn de Valera,
once again,
did nothing to stop him, and
Arthur Griffith was forced to make the comment,
"That
Michael Collins
had "won" the War and he was proud to have his name
associated with him."
Cathal
Brugha's
negative
"personal" attack on
Michael Collins bought in a very sour
note to the proceedings, which was already hard enough in the circumstances and
"upset" many of those present, who now began to realise
there was more to the "Anti
- Treaty" stance then they first realised.
Sean Mac Eoin, who had always been for
a "total"
Irish
Republic, stated that he voted
"For"
the
"Treaty"
as he fully
realised the "implications" if they continued on with
the "Anglo - Irish War" against the
"Military" might of
the British Imperial Empire and
Joseph Mac Grath
also stated that he was in "favour" of it also.
Eamonn Duggan
wanted it known that he "signed" it under "no" duress,
but
Peadar O Donnell, Erskine Childers,
Harry Boland,
Austin
Stack and
Cathal Brugha were totally
"against"
it.
The
Anglo - Irish Treaty Debate
was
then
"closed," and the "vote"
was taken, resulting in
64 "For" the
"Anglo - Irish Treaty" and
57 "Against"
the "Treaty," while the vote of
Eoin Mac Neill
as the "Chairman"
was not required.
Although
Eamonn
de Valera
as an M.P.
represented
East Co. Clare
in the north - west of the Munster Province, who had voted
17 to
5 "For" the
"Anglo - Irish
Treaty," he personally took it upon himself to "disregard" their democratic instructions,
and cast his vote to suite his own "personal" outlook, while
Frank Drohan from
Clonmel on the other hand who also
"opposed" the "Anglo
-Irish Treaty"
had "resigned" before hand, rather than "compromise" his instructions to vote "for" it
and
Laurence Ginnell
who
was also "against" the "Anglo - Irish
Treaty" did not attend, but sent a
telegram instead, but his "postal" vote was not allowed.
Robert Barton
who had also "previously" voted
"For" the
"Anglo - Irish Treaty" and had even
"signed" it personally himself,
was now "against" it due mainly to
the "artificial partition"
of the 6
Counties in Ireland,
but he had
allowed his commonsense to overrule his personal
feelings as did
George Gavin Duffy.
To defeat the "Anglo - Irish
Treaty," with no other
"alternative" to put forward to replace it, would have meant outright
"War" against the
"might" of the
British Imperial Government
"again" and this was now a "deciding factor" in everyone's
mind.
Among the
64
Dail Eireann members who voted
"For" the "Anglo
- Irish Treaty"
/ Is Toil were
Among the 57
Dail Eireann
members who voted
"Against" the "Anglo
- Irish Treaty"
/
Ni Toil were
E. Aylward,
Count
O Beirne,
Harry Boland,
Cathal Brugha, Domhnall O Buachalla,
P.J. Cahill, Mrs.
O Callaghan,
Frank Carty, Domhnall O
Ceallachain, Sean T. O Ceallaigh,
Mrs.
Clarke, M.P. Colivet, Art O Connor,
Erskine Childers, Daniel Corkery, Con Collins,
Dr.
Crowley,
Dr.
Cusack, Seamus O Daimhin,
Eamonn Dee,
Tomas Derrig, Joseph O Dougherty,
Joseph Mac Donagh, Tomas Donnachu,
Seamus
Doyle, Dr.
Ada English,
Sean
Mac Entee, Sean Etchingham, Frank Fahey,
Dr.
Fearon, S. O Flaherty,
Seamus Mac
Gearailt, Laurence Ginnell, T. Mac Guire,
Tomas Hunter, J.J. O Kelly, David
Kent, James Lennon, Sean O Mahoney,
Countess
Constance Markievicz, Liam Mellowes,
P.J. Moloney, Sean Moylan, Charles Murphy,
Sean Nolan, Mrs.
Pearse,
Count
Plunkett, Seamus Robinson, Eamonn de
Roiste, P.J. Rutledge, Dr.
Ryan, Phillip Shanahan, Austin Stack,
Professor
Stockley, Mary Mac Swiney,
Sean Mac
Swiney, Brian O hUigin,
and
Eamonn de Valera.
January 9th:
At the next meeting of the
2nd Dail Eireann / Irish Assembly the staid
Cathal Brugha tried
hard to get
Arthur Griffith to change his mind over the
"Anglo - Irish Treaty," but he stood firmly with
Michael Collins
for whom he had gained great "respect" and
Eamonn de Valera
then put forward his "resignation again" as the
Priomh Aire
of
the 2nd
Dail Eireann,
but was re - nominated by
Mrs.
Clarke and
Liam Mellowes for re
- election once again as the leader of the
Dail / Assembly
and was then "defeated"
60
votes to
58 when he together with
Liam
de Roistre / Roche
and
Thomas O Donnell "refused" to
cast a "vote." Besides this
2 of
the "Pro - Treaty"
members had also "abstained" from voting, while another
2 of the
"Pro - Treaty" members had voted for
Eamonn de Valera
who informed the meeting that he,
"Could not "co -
operate" with the "Pro - Treaty" members of the Dail
Assembly,
but he and his "followers" would be there against any
"outside" enemy."
Cathal Brugha also stated at this
time,
"That he would not "hinder nor co - operate" with the
"Pro - Treaty" Irish Government."
Michael Collins
then put forward
Arthur Griffith
to be the new
Priomh Aire of the
Dail Eireann
/ Irish Assembly as
Ireland
needed "stable" government
to stop "anarchy," and
Eamonn de Valera asked him to put forward his policies, and
Arthur
Griffith replied
that he would "retain the same position" until the
"elections" and that the "vote" for the introduction of the "Irish
Free State"
would be put to the population of
Ireland
to make the final decision and
Eamonn de Valera
then requested all those who had voted "Against"
the
"Anglo - Irish Treaty" to meet with him
the next day, and left with all of his
"Anti
- Treaty" group to further "widen the
split" amongst the
Irish
leaders.
He was
doing the same as he had done in
America with the
Clann na Gael
and the
Friends of Irish
Freedom, but by creating this "split" among the
Irish
leaders themselves at this time he was also "splitting the loyalty" of the
Irish
population, and by these actions he was
to
ensure that an
Irish
"Civil War" was to now occur in
Ireland until
1923.
Eamonn de Valera
walked out of the Dail Eireann meeting followed by his
"Anti
- Treaty" followers, as the election for the
Priopmh Aire of the
Dail Eireann had begun, and
Michael Collins who was now really "upset"
with the futility of their antics called out to them."Go
on, deserters all, from the Irish Nation in her
hour of need, we will stand by her, we will call on the
people of Ireland
to rally to us."
Eammon
Ceannt then replied
with,"Up the Republic" as
Robert Barton, who
had been of two minds,also left the
Dail
Eireann
meeting to also follow
after
Eamonn de Valera.
With
61 of the
DT members
still present
William T. Cosgrave
moved the election of the "new"
President
for the
Dail Eireann
be put, and
Arthur Griffith
was "elected,"
and Michael Collins became the
"Minister for Finance,"
George Gavin Duffy
the
"Minister for Foreign Affairs" and
Eamonn Duggan the
"Minister for Home Affairs."
4
of those who had "signed" the original "Anglo - Irish Treaty"
were now "newly" elected to the
Irish Dail
Eireann Cabinet
with
William T. Cosgrave becoming the
"Minister for Local Government,"
Richard Mulcahy the
"Minister for Defence"
and
Kevin O Higgins
the "Minister for
Economic Affairs."
Eamonn de Valera was to
return once again, for the afternoon session
of the Dail
Eireann, were he also stated once again,
"That his group would not "stand in the way" of the
Dail Eireann
/ Irish Assembly carrying out
their duties." Arthur
Griffith in reply said,
"All I ask of my colleagues against me is not to throw obstacles in our way."
Erskine Childers
kept "interjecting" until
Arthur Griffith, who was a mild mannered man, could not stand him
any more and
responded with, "I will not reply to
any Englishman in this chamber."
January 10th: Arthur Griffith stated that he would remain as the Priomh Aire of the 2nd Dail Eireann, to retain the "Status Quo" as an Irish Republic until the Irish Free State "elections" occurred, and this would then not merge the Irish Republic Dail Eireann with the proposed "Irish Free State Government."
January 11th:
Arthur Griffith
as the new
Priomh Aire of the Dail Eireann
sent out notices to the
representatives of the
26
Irish Free
State
Counties
to attend a meeting of the
Dail Eireann to be held in
3
days
time, and at this meeting they were to "ratify"
the "Anglo
-
Irish Treaty" and elect the
Irish Free State
Provisional Government,
while the Irish
Volunteers / I.R.A. under their original
"Oath" owed their allegiance to the
Republic of Ireland
that was now represented by the
2nd Dail Eireann, which was still in existence,
but under the "Anglo -
Irish
Treaty"
it was not
to exist after the "elections" were held, and they would then come
under the banner of the
Irish
Provisional Government
who would be taking over in the
26 Counties
in the Connacht Province, the Leinster
Province,
the Munster Province
and the 3 Counties rejected from the
9 Counties
by the Ascendancy in the Ulster
Province for havng too many Irish
Catholics in them to gerrymander.
The "Anti - Treaty"
I.R.A. Volunteers, were to form into
a
"new" association to be known as the "Irregular
IRA," under
the leadership of
Liam Mellowes, Rory
O Connor, Oscar Traynor,
Sean Russell
and others
who were also "against" the "Anglo -
Irish Treaty"
and with this in mind they now wanted to hold an
Irish Volunteer
Convention, and
they approached
Richard Mulcahy the new
"Minister of Defence"
in the Dail Eireann / Irish Assembly who informed them that the new
Irish Army would be the army of
the "Irish
Free State"
who would hold the same position in relation to the
"Minister" and the
Dail Eireann /
Irish Assembly.
January 12th:
The
"political" Sinn
Fein Party
held
their Ard
Comhairle with
Eamonn de Valera still in as their
President
who had by now shed himself of any "responsibilities" for the
actual government of
Ireland, while
Arthur Griffith and
Michael Collins during the same period had
now taken on "more" responsibility to bring about the proposed
Irish Free State.
January 14th:
The
"Anglo
- Irish Treaty"
was
formally "ratified" with the Dail
Eireann / Iris Assembly meeting at the
Mansion House in Dublin, and set about
"electing" the
Irish
Provisional
Government,
to be "officially" recognized by the
British
Imperial Government,
to carry out
the terms of the "Anglo - Irish
Treaty" and they
were then elected from the
64
DT members who were
"Pro - Treaty" and the
4 Unionists from the
Trinity
College. (Those to be elected
within the next 12 months in
the next "General Irish Elections
were to form the "official" government of the
Irish Free State. None of the
"Anti
- Treaty" members were present, including
Eamonn de Valera
or any of his followers, and he was also personally able in the future to
"change"
the minds of many who at first had thought the
"Treaty" terms to be good, and the
I.R.A.
Volunteers were then also "divided" in their
opinions on the
"Treaty,"
and
their "attitudes" were to be the most important as they still had
no "civil" authority over them.
It had already been decided not to complicate
the position now held by
Arthur Griffith the newly elected
Priomh Aire of the
Dail Eireann / Irish Assembly, who still represented the
overall
Irish Republic. Because of the necessity
for this, Arthur Griffith would not hold any "post" in the
Irish Provisional
Government
who would now maintain the government in the 26 Counties
until the
elections for the "Irish Free State"
were held. Despite this, it was also decided that the Dail
Eireann / Irish Assembly
under Arthur Griffith, would function
"side by side" with the new
Irish Provisional Government for the purposes of co - operation with the
British Imperial Government during the
"changeover"
period.
In the meantime the proposed
"Irish
Provisional Government"
was to be run under
the control of
Michael Collins, who was now
31
year of age, as its
Chairman and
Joseph Devlin as their
"General
Commander"
of the Irish Military Forces and
the "Minister for Local
Government," who was to retain that position until
1923 and also
"elected" to the
Irish Provisional
Government
were
William T.
Cosgrave, Eamonn Duggan, P.J. Hogan, Fionan
Lynch, Joseph Mac Grath, Eoin Mac Neill
and
Kevin O Higgins.
Michael Collins
who was already in charge of "Finance," now also had the further responsibilities for
14
other Irish
Provisional Government Departments,
and some of the "members" now held positions in both the
Dail Eireann /
Irish Assembly
and the Irish
Provisional Government
in anticipation of the
"Irish Free State"
coming into being within 12 months.
It had been
750
years since the "oppression" of
England had begun, and it was
also the
British
Imperial Military
Forces who had fired the "first" shots in the previous
"Anglo - Irish War,"
when on
July 26th.,1914
their
"occupation"
forces, in the form of the
King's Own Scottish Borderers had
killed 2
innocent Irishmen and an
Irishwoman and wounded
30
others in the crowd by the
River Liffey.
John Redmond, the leader of the redundant
Irish Parliamentary Party then
had previously made a statement that, "The
people of Ireland,
who had sent
200,000 men to fight
and die for England, would live to reap the rewards from the
British Imperial Government." These
rewards as usual had seen
Irishmen
in Ireland once again
"killed" in front of their wives and children, their
towns "burned" and "looted," and innocent Irish people
"executed" with an
unchecked Imperial ferocity and the homes of numerous innocent
civilians in Ireland "destroyed" and all of this had been carried out with
the usual
Imperial English "stupidity,
insensitivity and bigotry." This time in Irish History it had been the
ordinary people in
Ireland, the
"Mere Irish
/
Bog Irish" who had started out with
"no" arms and no "Landed Gentry" to represent them, that had
succeeded in "driving out" the
British Imperial Government by the use of
"common sense," "determination" and
"guerrilla warfare" and in doing this
they had shown the way for many "other" Countries still
under the "domination" of the
British Imperial Empire
to do the same, which they
eventually were to do, for those in authority in
England were to continue to "learn nothing"
from their "oppressive" treatment of the people of
Ireland and its final repercussions.
January 16th:
The
Irish
Provisional Government, now under the
control of Michael Collins as its
Chairman, received their
"political powers" from
the
British Imperial Government
's Viceroy,
Viscount
Fitz Alan
of Derwent,
who was now the
British Imperial Government's appointed representative at their
headquarters in
the
Dublin Castle (The Devil's 1/2 acre) that had been
the centre of
Irish
"oppression" in Ireland for so many
"Centuries,"
and it was now given over into
Irish
hands, and
Ireland
was
now given
British "Dominion"
status in the
British Imperial Empire.
By this time also, the administration
of the
"Official" Unionist Government
in
the 6 Counties "artificially
partitioned" from the 9 Counties in the
Ulster Province wasn't going "too good," and their
"relations" were bad, and it was expected that their government over these
6 Counties would be very
"short lived" and
Ireland
would soon be once again "united"
as the 32 Counties it really was as they had already been forced to
introduce a "Special Class "B" Constabulary",
made up of non - Catholics from
their "Official"
Unionist Volunteer Force / U.V.F
to "restore order" there to be
generically known as the
"B" Specials."
It was now up to the
Irish Provisional
Government
to
introduce their own
"Constitution" and conduct their own
General Elections
within a year for the proposed
Irish
Free State, which would then see the end of the
Dail Eireann /
Irish Assembly
followed by an
Irish
Parliament
of the Irish Free State
The "Official" Unionists in control in the 6 Counties "artificially partitioned" from the 9 Counties in the Ulster Province, which were previously set up for the continuation of the Conservative Ascendancy there, but still under the overall control of the British Imperial Government, were given the power to "opt out" of the Irish Free State, with the River Bann to be the proposed border in collusion with the British Imperial Government who had by now divided the 32 Counties of the whole of Ireland.
Liam Mellowes, Rory O Connor,
Oscar Traynor, Sean Russell
and
O Donovan who were previously
I.R.A. Volunteer members, who were
against the "Anglo - Irish
Treaty" now stated their
"allegiance" was only to the
Irish
Republic, and they all joined forces to bring about
internal "troubles," which were only destined to lead on to
"Civil War"
in Ireland, bringing further great "distress" to the
overall
Irish population.
January 18th:
As the
I.R.A. Volunteers had not held a
Convention since
1918, they were still not
"officially" under the control of the Dail Eireann / Irish Assembly
so a meeting was held with
Richard Mulcahy,
the "Minister of Defence"
of the Irish Provisional Government and the
General Headquarters
Staff to discuss the holding of an immediate
I.R.A. Volunteer Convention,
so that the
Executive of the
I.R.A. could gain "official control" over the
I.R.A.
Volunteers and it was set down to be held on
February 5th,
but as this was prior to the
British Imperial Government
Military Forces leaving, any sign of a "split"
in the I.R.A.
ranks would "stop" there departure, and they would then not
hand over their barracks to a non
- Treaty body.
Liam Lynch
proposed that they "postpone" the
"Convention" for another
2 months, but
Rory O Connor
was "upset" by this delay and he said that he would call his own
I.R.A.
Convention and also that he was not concerned with any undertakings given
by
Eamonn de Valera
and
Ernest O Malley
then came out and stated publicly, that he would not be taking any
"orders" from
Richard Mulcahy the new
"Minister of Defence" in the
Irish Provisional Government,
and
random "raids" then began to occur on the remaining
British Imperial Military
Forces and
the
Dublin Castle's R.I.C police,
carried out by those who were now among the "Anti - Treaty"
I.R.A. members, which bought
no honour to anyone who was involved.
January 21st:
Ernest O Malley
completely "ignored the orders" from the
Irish Provisional Government's G.H.Q.,
and
Seamus Robinson
carried out an "attack" on the The
Nationalist, which was a
"Pro
- Treaty" newspaper,
while
many other similar disturbing incidents occurred throughout the
Country
also,
and Arthur Griffith, by now, was of the opinion that if there was
going to be a "Civil War" in Ireland, the sooner it came
about the better
and
January 21st - 22nd: Winston Churchill who was the British Imperial Government's Colonial Secretary had meetings with Michael Collins and stated after the meetings that, "Arthur Griffith, Michael Collins, Richard Mulcahy and Kevin O Higgins were men who were realists, they feared God, they loved their Country and they "kept their word."
The
Clann Na Gael / The Organization
in
America
was still under the leadership of
John Devoy who was
also "Pro
- Treaty," but it too was now "split" also, into
"Pro - Treaty" and
"Anti -Treaty" factions there, and the
"Anti
- Treaty" group "reorganized" themselves under
Joseph Mac Garritty
there,
who was originally from
Carrickmore
in
Co. Tyrone
in Central Southern Ulster, while there other leader
Luke Dillon was originally from
Co. Sligo
in the north - west of the Connacht
Province and they were to give their allegiance
to the "Anti - Treaty"
I.R.A. Irregulars when they were "later on" to go it alone and were to
break
away from the Dail
Eireann / Irish Assembly and the
Irish Provisional
Government.